Relevance to the topic of discussion, applicability, and insight.
Appropriate audience and word choice are specific, purposeful, dynamic, and varied—grammar, spelling, and punctuation.
Inclusion of the student outcomes explored in the discussion and the role-specific competencies as applicable. That is the most important, please. I lost 10 points always because of this part.
Rigor, currency, and relevance of the scholarly references
Relevance to the topic of discussion, applicability, and insight.
Appropriate a