Post two replies of at least 450 words each by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Sunday, except replies for the third Discussion which are due by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Friday of the final Module: Week. For each thread and reply, analysis must be supported with a minimum of 3 scholarly sources other than the course textbook and materials. Each source must be cited in current APA format. Each thread and each reply must include both full citations in a reference list at the end of each post, and short-form in-text citations. Acceptable sources include books, legal and business journals, legal cases, the law (cases, statutes, regulations, etc.), the Bible, biblical commentary, etc. Dictionaries and other web sources that lack scholarly support are not acceptable sources. Any sources cited must be current to the issue (e.g. Bible commentaries may by applicable from any age, but articles discussing current legal or healthcare practices may no longer be relevant after 5 or 10 years). A well-developed, complete worldview analysis of the situation requires more than simply adding a Bible verse at the end of the post. Each thread must include at least 2 separate verses from Scripture, quoted and applied as an integral part of the discussion of the applicable issues in the context of a biblical worldview. Each reply will include at least 1 Scripture verse integrated in the same manner.
1.
Case Study
Wisdom Kumah
School of Business, Liberty University
Author Note
Wisdom Kumah
I have no known conflict of interest to disclose.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Wisdom Kumah.
Email: wkumah@liberty.edu
Case Study
The decision to set up a business is just the beginning step of many
steps. Kubasek et al. (2020) posit that “deciding what form of business
to create is one of the most important decisions a business makes” (p.
463). There are different forms of business ownership. These include
sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, an LLC, and a joint
venture. Each form of business ownership may be created according to the
business needs. From this case, a sole proprietorship and partnership
may not be the ideal business ownership for Shania. For a sole
proprietorship business, funding for the business is limited to the
personal funds of the owner, and liabilities for all debts are unlimited
hence. Partnership business will create personal liabilities for all
partners and Shania may be liable for the liabilities of other partners.
A joint venture acts just like a partnership and has unlimited
liabilities. Disputes between the partners may stunt the growth of the
business. Corporations are legal entities and can sue and be sued. They
are great for tax advantages, but their complex nature requires extra
expenditures to run. This form of business ownership is mostly practiced
by large companies such as Walmart, and Nike, among others hence may
not be suitable for Shania’s coffee shop. The ideal form of business
ownership that will match Shania’s needs is the limited liability
company (LLC). With an LLC, the liability of the company is only limited
to the companies’ assets. Members of an LLC have the opportunity to
avoid double taxation and also have the choice of how they want to be
taxed (Kubasek et al., 2020).
Shania intends to name her business venture “The Gathering Place”.
After performing a business availability search on “Colorado Secretary
of State business database” it is unfortunate that the name she intends
to use is not available in the state of Colorado. The name is currently
not registered as a trademark in the state of Colorado however because
the name is not available for use Shania cannot use it for her coffee
shop. The name she intends to use is quite vague and does not really
portray what the business is about. Finding the right name for a new
business can have a significant impact on its success. The wrong name
can do worse than fail to connect with customers; it can also result in
insurmountable business and legal hurdles. In contrast, a clear,
powerful name can be extremely helpful in the marketing and branding
efforts of the new establishment. The name of a business venture is the
main identity of the business and should be well thought of. It should
portray what the business is about. Businesses may deliberately choose
names that are aimed to influence their customers. For example, a firm
might claim to provide high-quality service by including the word
“quality” or “best” in its name or to charge low prices by calling
itself a “discount” provider. When consumers cannot verify the claims
implied by a firm’s name, however, they might dismiss them as cheap talk
(McDevitt, 2014, para. 1). Another name that is available in Colorado
that portrays the Christian identity as well as what the business is
about is “Caffeine Ministry”. This name is currently available and not
registered as a trademark in the state of Colorado. Shania should
consider “Caffeine Ministry” as a business name since it is available,
and it also shows what the business is about.
Shania is a Christian who has an honest intention of establishing a
Christian coffeehouse near Denver Colorado. She intends to promote
cohesion between the Christian community by establishing a common ground
where Christians can buy coffee. Taking on the massive challenge of
starting a business with the financial risks involved and vast amounts
of time and dedication needed requires a sizable leap of faith. It is
faith, along with vision, that propels the entrepreneurs to forge ahead
when others hold back. Proverbs 16:3 “commit your work to the Lord, and
your plans will be established” (English Standard Version).
There were several people who showed interest in Shania’s coffeehouse
business. Her husband, Marvin, is opened to contribute capital to the
business, but he has no interest in participating in its day-to-day
operations or management. Shania should accept this form of assistance
from her husband. In this case, the husband would serve as a dormant
partner and still enjoy some of the profits from the company. It may be
wise for Shania not to engage her husband as an active partner if he is
not willing to participate in the day-to-day operations or management of
the firm. Family businesses may promote unity among family members or
create conflicts that can harm the organization and disunite family
members (Wielsma & Brunninge, 2019). Colossians 3:18-19 says that
“wives, submit to your husbands, as is fitting in the Lord. husbands,
love your wives, and do not be harsh with them” (English Standard
Version). Married couples in business should respect one another and
should not bring their personal lives into the business operations.
Her sister, Kelsey, would like to be involved as a new member of the Christian faith, but
her husband does not want her to get involved. I do not believe that Shania should allow her
sister to be involved in an active role because it would likely cause problems for Kelsey’s
marriage. 1 Corinthians 7:39 says “a wife is bound to her husband as long as he lives” (English
Standard Version). Regardless of the difference in beliefs between Kelsey and her husband, their
union should not have interference from Shania or her business. Perhaps Shania could seek
advice from her sister or allow her to participate in a small role that would not take her away
from her duties to her husband and children.
Shania’s neighbor, Carlos, is a non-Christian who has also expressed
an interest in participating in the business as a way to earn extra
income. Carlos is a non-believer who believes that Shania’s idea will be
popular based on the religious population in their area. It seems as if
Carlos is interested in exploiting the faiths of the community to
benefit himself. Shania should not allow Carlos to be involved with her
business. The Holy Bible teaches us not to enter into a business
partnership with non-believers. 2 Corinthians 6:14-15 says that “do not
be unequally yoked with unbelievers. For what partnership has
righteousness with lawlessness? Or what fellowship has light with
darkness? What accord has Christ with Belial? Or what portion does a
believer share with an unbeliever?” (English Standard Version). This
means that, as Christians, we should not make partnerships with
unbelievers as this will defy the will of God.
In conclusion, all the people that showed interest in the active
operations of Shania’s coffeehouse business seem not to be a perfect
fit. “Findings from a nationally representative sample of new businesses
show that male-led businesses are more likely to survive than
female-led businesses and that the road can be rocky for female
entrepreneurs” (Yang, 2019, p. 951). Nevertheless, with God all things
are possible. I would recommend she runs the business herself or seek
someone from the community or church who has the same faith as she does.
This would promote better business partner relationships.
References
English standard version bible. (2016). Bible Gateway. http://www.biblegateway.com/ (Original work published 2001)
Kubasek, N. K., Browne, M. N., Barkacs, L., Herron, D., & Dhooge, L. (2020). Biblical worldview edition of dynamic business law (2nd ed.). N. J. Kippenhan (Ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill Education.
McDevitt, R. C. (2014). “A” business by any other name: Firm name choice as a signal of firm quality. The Journal of Political Economy, 122(4), 909-944. https://doi.org/10.1086/676333
Yang, T., & del Carmen Triana, M. (2019). Set up to fail: Explaining when women-led businesses are more likely to fail. Journal of Management, 45(3), 926-954. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206316685856
Wielsma, A. J., & Brunninge, O. (2019). “Who am I? who are we?”
understanding the impact of family business identity on the development
of individual and family identity in business families. Journal of Family Business Strategy, 10(1), 38-48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfbs.2019.01.006
BUSI 561 Case Study 1_WKumah-1.docx
2.
As
a sole proprietor Shania would own an unincorporated business on her
own and she would pay personal income tax on profits earned by her
business. It is the easiest type of business to establish or take apart
due to lack of government regulation. It is a popular choice for sole
owners of business, but it can be a challenge in the name she is wanting
to use because it is not necessary. Most use their own names. The main
benefit is the pass-through tax advantage, the ease of creations and the
low fees of creation and maintenance. The lack of government regulation
would make it more susceptible to being taken a part. I think the
challenge with this type of business is there is no separate legal
entity and as a result the business owner is not exempt from liabilities
incurred by the business. There is also the unlimited liability that
goes beyond the business to the owner, and the difficulty in getting
capital funding, specifically through established channels such as
obtaining bank loans or line of credit. With her husband willing to
contribute towards her business this may be a non-issue although he
would be her only investor. She also is considering a Limited Liability
Company (LLC) which the main benefit to this would be that her liability
would be limited to the amount of their investment in the LLC. She
would not be personally liable for the debts of the LLC whereas if she
is just sole proprietor, she will be liable. Of course, this would all
be dependent on her following the rules associated with an LLC. This is
an appealing option and I think it would be a viable option in the
future for her but considering that she has her sister and neighbor
interested in this business opportunity I think a joint venture would be
best. She could establish a contract with both Kelsey and Carlos that
would outline money, property, and any assets that they would bring to
the business, plus how the business will be managed. This could
eventually be structured as an LLC when she sees consistent profits and
consumers.
Looking through the database search, it is very noticeable
that “The Gathering Place” is used in multiple names of other places, so
the concern would be that the name she is wanting for her coffeehouse
could easily be confused with several other business that are named
similarly. This seems to be a very common name for businesses but is not
trademarked. I would probably advise Shania to think of a more unique
name for her business to avoid this issue. "Strong, successful brands
are authentic, and to be authentic the name has to be aligned with what
the company is.” (F. Matthew, 2015) I would recommend a name that
represents her faith, I would possibly lean towards a biblical name that
represents her business ethic, her faith, and the company, in this case
a coffeehouse. She will want her coffeehouse to stand out not only to
the Christian community but to all consumers as her coffeehouse.
The obvious choice to me would be her sister, Kelsey because
she is also a Christian and shares is her sister’s faith and values. The
potential problem with this would be Kelsey’s husband, he wants her to
be a full-time stay-at-home mom and could have objections to her being a
part of the business. As we know, the Bible tells us how sacred
marriage is and that the importance of wives submitting to their
husbands. “Wives submit yourselves to your own husbands as you do to the
Lord. For the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of
the church, his body, of which he is the savior. Now as the church
submits to Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in
everything” (Ephesians 5:22-24, New International Version). Her husband
Marvin shown interest in her business and is willing to contribute to
the capital of the business but does not want to participate in any of
the business operations. This would be good for her as a small business
owner, she could use as much capital assistance she can find. Another
person to consider is Carlos who is a non-Christian. Looking to the
Bible, Paul writes, “do not be yoked together with unbelievers. For what
do righteousness and wickedness have in common? Or what fellowship can
light have with darkness?” (2 Corinthians 6:14, New International
Version). I think the thing to consider is Carlos thinking of the
“Christian thing has potential” which makes it look as if Carlos sees
this more as marketing than as a business. Shania is looking to opening a
Christian coffeehouse, her business success will have a lot to do with
her beliefs, values, and overall morals. Her employees will be a direct
reflection of her and the coffeehouse. Ultimately her decision will
result in having a discussion with all those interested in partnering
with her. With her sister, she will need to have the discussion of the
implications of marriage and what it should mean. With Carlos, simply
her beliefs and his do not align and that he would be a good fit for her
business.
(Blair, E., Marcum T., Fry F. 2009) The Disproportionate Costs of
Forming LLCs Vs. Corporations: The Impact on Small Firm Liability
Protection, Journal of Small Business Strategy; Peoria Vol. 20, Iss. 2
Fontana, P. K. (2010). Choosing the right legal form of business :
the complete guide to becoming a sole proprietor, partnership, LLC, or
corporation . Atlantic Pub. Group.
Flamm, Matthew. "The secret to naming businesses; Ookles, anyone?
Anyone? Professional branders share naming rights--and wrongs." Crain's New York Business 18 May 2015: 0003. Business Insights: Global. Web. 30 June 2021.
Jain, S. (2021, April 2). BIBLICAL BUSINESS NAMES. Give a Good Name. https://www.good-name.org/biblical-business-names/